Review: "Middlemarch" by George Eliot
Middlemarch is available for free download from our ebook catalog.
Middlemarch is one of those books that was born to be read as an ebook. This sounds strange to say about a book that was written over 100 years ago, but it's true. I had tried reading this in pbook--a hefty and intimidating 900-page thing--several years ago and didn't make it though the first few chapters. Just keeping the book open to the right page took considerable effort. On ebook, there is no heft to tow around, no stack of unread pages to intimidate you. If you set up your ereader properly, you don't even notice how far you've read or still have to go. You can revel, unhindered, in Eliot's beautiful prose for days on end. For I won't lie, days and days, possibly weeks it will take you to read this.
Upon finishing, you might even feel you need to read it over again, which was my feeling. I felt lost for much of this book, particularly the beginning where Eliot introduces a large amount of characters. She does not skimp on details, so one is inundated with particulars about everyone and everything. I feel that I could give this book several reads and still never catch everything that is of importance. I again realized the need for a re-reading while watching the 1994 BBC adaptation. There were so many scenes, particularly dramatic ones involving Dorothea and Ladislaw, that I didn't fully understand in the book. I didn't catch a certain innuendo, implication, scandalous look or touch. This is why there can sometimes be a reason for seeing the adaptation first.
My ineptitude as a reader aside, I found Middlemarch's characters absolutely delightful. Even the characters we aren't supposed to like--Bulstrode and Casaubon, even Raffles!--are written with such a multi-faceted personality that you can't completely categorize them as good or bad. Brooke and Ladislaw quickly became my favorites, the first for comic relief and the latter as the tortured, Byronic hero. In the film adaptation both of these characters were superbly cast. We have discussed our love for Rufus Sewell (Ladislaw) and his casting possibilities on other posts. Here is where we discovered him, and he is wonderful.
To conclude, if you feel inclined to pick up this tome, take your time with it. Don't feel guilty if you want to watch the film adaptation first. And if you've tried before and never got through it, try it on ebook!
Discussion
Reply to JaneGS
Support Free Ebooks
"The Ultimate Longhorn Reading List", published in the May/June 2007 issue of the University of Texas ex-students' Association magazine, "Alcalde" lists "Middlemarch as one of the 89 ultimate must-reads. One contributor commented that Virginia Woolf once observed "this is the only novel ever written for a grown-up readership!"
I often say that Austen is my favorite author, but Middlemarch is my favorite book. I love your comments about it being made for an e-reader. I'm planning on rereading it later this year, and maybe I will try it on my new iPad.
Like you, I find all the characters so interesting and real, and Dorothea is one of my favorite heroines of all literature.
Dorothea is great because she's very conservative, but Eliot makes you see her point of view so clearly that she's not annoyingly so. I love that Eliot enables the reader to sympathize with all the characters, even the "bad" ones. I truly felt for Bulstrode at the end! Though I love Austen to pieces, I find her sympathy for characters (especially the "bad" ones) lacking compared to Eliot's.